Do Blinds and Cellular Shades Really Save Energy? What the Tests Show
Windows are the weak spot in most homes’ insulation. Replacing them is expensive, so most of us cover them instead — usually with whatever blinds came with the house. Do better window coverings actually cut energy bills? U.S. national laboratories have measured it.
Why windows matter
- According to the energy-efficiency council ACEEE, about 47 million U.S. homes (42%) have single-pane windows, and another 46 million have double-pane clear glass — both lose far more heat than modern windows.
- Only about 2% of homes replace their windows each year, mainly because of cost (U.S. DOE).
- About 60% of window coverings in U.S. homes are vinyl or metal blinds (DOE) — which do little to stop heat.
What the field tests found
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory tested window attachments in matched lab homes. Its results, summarized by ACEEE:
| Window attachment | Heating energy saved | Cooling energy saved |
|---|---|---|
| Cellular (honeycomb) shades | 7.5–22% | 4–16.5% |
| Exterior storm windows | 9–11.5% | 8% |
| Interior storm windows / panels | 6.5–10% | 3.5–5% |
A U.S. Department of Energy fact sheet adds that cellular shades saved up to 20% on heating energy and up to 15% on total heating and cooling energy compared with no shades. The honeycomb cells trap a layer of air against the glass — a little like adding another pane.
What that means in dollars
For a home spending $1,200 a year on heating and $600 on cooling, with 10 windows at about $80 each ($800 total):
| Attachment | Yearly savings | Payback on $800 |
|---|---|---|
| Cellular shades | $114 – $363 (middle ≈ $238) | ≈ 3½ years |
| Exterior storm windows | $156 – $186 | ≈ 4½–5 years |
| Interior storm windows | $99 – $150 | ≈ 6½ years |
Same $800 cost used for comparison; storm windows usually cost more per window than shades. ACEEE notes low-e storm windows cost about 30% of a replacement window and pay back in roughly 4 to 14 years. Use your own bills and prices in the window coverings savings calculator.
How you use them decides the savings
The test results assume coverings are used well. Left half-open all year, they save much less. For the biggest savings:
- Winter nights: close every shade — this is when windows lose the most heat.
- Winter days: open shades on sunny, south-facing windows to let free solar heat in; keep others closed.
- Summer days: close shades on windows in direct sun, especially east and west in morning and afternoon.
- Fit matters: inside-mount shades that fit snugly in the frame (or have side tracks) block air movement much better than loose ones.
- Motorized or automated shades make good operation effortless if you won’t open and close them by hand every day.
Shades or new windows?
Replacement windows can cost many times more than shades or storm windows. If your windows are structurally sound, attachments are usually the cheaper first step; replacement makes more sense when frames are rotten, drafty beyond repair, or you are renovating anyway. Either way, insulating the attic often saves more — see what attic insulation really saves.
Savings vary with climate, window orientation, the existing windows and how the coverings are used. Figures are from field tests and are not guaranteed.
Frequently asked questions
Do cellular shades really save energy?
Yes. In Pacific Northwest National Laboratory field tests, cellular shades saved 7.5–22% of heating energy and 4–16.5% of cooling energy. A DOE fact sheet reports up to 20% heating savings and up to 15% total heating and cooling savings compared with no shades.
Are cellular shades better than regular blinds?
For energy, yes. The air pockets in cellular shades insulate the window, while vinyl or metal slat blinds mainly block light. The DOE estimates window attachments can save about 15% of a household’s heating and cooling energy compared with vinyl blinds.
How much money can energy-efficient window coverings save?
For a home spending $1,200 a year on heating and $600 on cooling, cellular shades used well would save roughly $114 to $363 a year based on field-test ranges, paying back in about three to four years at $80 per window.
When should I close my blinds to save energy?
Close them on winter nights and on hot summer days when sun hits the window. On sunny winter days, open them on south-facing windows to let in free solar heat.
Are storm windows worth it?
Often. Field tests found exterior storm windows saved about 9–11.5% of heating energy and interior storm panels 6.5–10%. ACEEE notes low-e storm windows cost around 30% of a replacement window and pay back in about 4 to 14 years.