CDs vs High-Yield Savings vs Treasury Bills: Where to Keep Cash
If you have cash you want to keep safe — an emergency fund, a house deposit, money for next year’s tuition — three of the most popular choices are a certificate of deposit (CD), a high-yield savings account and U.S. Treasury bills. They are all very safe, but they differ in how quickly you can get your money, how the rate works and how they are taxed.
The quick comparison
| High-yield savings | CD | Treasury bills | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who backs it | FDIC / NCUA insurance up to $250,000 | FDIC / NCUA insurance up to $250,000 | U.S. government |
| Rate | Variable — can change any time | Fixed for the term | Fixed until maturity |
| Access to money | Any time | Penalty if withdrawn early | At maturity, or sell before (price can vary) |
| Terms | None | Usually 3 months – 5 years | 4 weeks – 52 weeks |
| State & local income tax | Taxed | Taxed | Exempt |
| Best for | Emergency fund | Money you won’t touch for a set time | Short-term savings, high-tax states |
Insurance limits are per depositor, per institution, per ownership category.
High-yield savings accounts
These are ordinary savings accounts — usually at online banks — that pay much more than a typical branch savings account. The rate is variable: when interest rates in the economy fall, the bank lowers it. In exchange you can withdraw at any time, which makes them the natural home for an emergency fund.
Certificates of deposit
A CD locks in a rate for a fixed term. If rates fall, your rate doesn’t; if rates rise, you are stuck until maturity. Taking money out early usually costs an early-withdrawal penalty of several months of interest. Example: $10,000 in a 12-month CD at 4.50% APR compounded monthly grows to $10,459.40 — see the CD calculator.
CD ladder: split your money across CDs that mature at different times (for example 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 years). Each year one matures, giving you access to part of the money while the rest earns longer-term rates.
Treasury bills
T-bills are short-term loans to the U.S. government, sold at a discount and repaid at full face value at maturity. You can buy them with as little as $100 at TreasuryDirect or through a brokerage account, and they are backed by the U.S. government. Their big advantage is tax: interest is exempt from state and local income tax.
Comparing rates fairly: the tax-equivalent yield
Because CD and savings interest is taxed by your state and T-bill interest is not, compare them on an after-tax basis. A bank product must pay about T-bill rate ÷ (1 − state tax rate) to match:
- T-bill at 4.00% in a state with a 5% income tax → a CD needs about 4.21% to match.
- T-bill at 4.00% in a state with a 9.3% income tax → a CD needs about 4.41%.
- In a state with no income tax, compare the rates directly.
Simplified — it ignores the deduction of state tax on a federal return. All three are taxed by the federal government.
APY vs APR: compare the right number
Banks advertise savings accounts and CDs by APY, which includes compounding. Treasury bill yields are usually quoted on a different basis, so check the “investment rate” or bond-equivalent yield when comparing. Use the effective annual rate calculator to convert between nominal and effective rates.
Which should you choose?
- Emergency fund → high-yield savings, for instant access.
- Money needed on a known date (tuition, a down payment) → a CD or T-bill maturing just before that date.
- You live in a high-tax state → T-bills often win after tax.
- You expect rates to fall → lock in with a longer CD.
- Above $250,000 → spread money across banks, or use Treasuries.
And remember inflation: if your rate is below inflation, your money is losing purchasing power even while the balance grows. The inflation calculator shows what your savings will really buy.
This is general education, not personal financial advice. Rates, tax rules and insurance limits can change — check current figures with your bank, TreasuryDirect and the FDIC.
Frequently asked questions
Is a CD or a high-yield savings account better?
A high-yield savings account is better for money you may need at any time, such as an emergency fund, because you can withdraw without penalty. A CD is better for money you will not need for a set period, because it locks in a fixed rate.
Are Treasury bills safer than CDs?
Both are considered very safe. CDs are insured by the FDIC or NCUA up to $250,000 per depositor, per institution, per ownership category; Treasury bills are backed by the U.S. government with no such limit.
Do you pay state tax on Treasury bills?
No. Interest from Treasury bills is subject to federal income tax but exempt from state and local income taxes, which can make them more attractive than CDs in high-tax states.
How do I compare a T-bill rate with a CD rate?
Divide the T-bill rate by (1 minus your state income tax rate) to get the rate a CD would need to match it after state tax. For a 4.00% T-bill in a 5% tax state, that is about 4.21%.
What happens if I need my money from a CD early?
You usually pay an early-withdrawal penalty, often a few months of interest depending on the term. Some banks offer no-penalty CDs at slightly lower rates.