Blackjack by the Numbers: What 6:5 Payouts, Bad Strategy and Insurance Really Cost

Blackjack can be one of the cheapest games in a casino — or one of the most expensive — depending on two things: the table rules and how you play your hands. To put numbers on both, I simulated 200 million hands.

The simulation

  • The game: 6 decks, reshuffled after 75% of the shoe; dealer checks for blackjack; double on any two cards and after splits; split up to four hands; split aces get one card; no surrender — a common U.S. game.
  • The variations: blackjack paying 3:2 or 6:5, and the dealer standing or hitting on soft 17.
  • Three ways to play: standard basic strategy; mimic the dealer (hit until 17, never double or split); and never bust (stand on any hard 12 or more).
  • 40 million hands for each basic-strategy game, 5 million for each of the others.

The results

GameBasic strategyMimic the dealerNever bust
3:2, dealer stands on soft 170.42%5.67%6.00%
3:2, dealer hits soft 170.66%6.25%5.97%
6:5, dealer stands on soft 171.80%7.00%7.45%
6:5, dealer hits soft 172.02%7.48%7.39%

House edge per starting bet. Basic-strategy figures are accurate to about ±0.04%; the others to about ±0.09%.

1. A 6:5 table costs more than four times as much

A blackjack comes about once every 21 hands (4.7% of hands in the simulation). At 3:2 a $25 blackjack pays $37.50; at 6:5 it pays $30. That small-looking difference raises the house edge by about 1.4 percentage points — from 0.42% to 1.80%, more than four times the cost. For $25 hands, 200 hands cost you about $21 on average at a 3:2 table and $90 at a 6:5 table. If the felt says “Blackjack pays 6 to 5,” find another table.

2. The soft-17 rule

When the dealer hits soft 17 (an ace counted as 11 plus a 6), they turn some 17s into better hands. That added 0.24% in the simulation — smaller than the 6:5 penalty, but it adds up. The rule is printed on the felt (“Dealer must hit soft 17” or “stand on all 17s”).

3. Strategy matters more than any rule

Players who make up their own strategy usually drift toward one of two ideas:

  • Mimic the dealer. It feels safe to play exactly like the house — but the house has one advantage you don’t: you act first. If you bust, you lose even if the dealer busts afterward. Playing like the dealer cost 5.67%, about 13 times basic strategy.
  • Never bust. Standing on 12–16 against every dealer card avoids busting, but it leaves you hoping the dealer busts — and against a 7 or higher, they usually don’t. It cost 6.00%.

Basic strategy — the mathematically best play for every hand, available on free printed cards — is the single biggest thing a player controls. Casinos allow you to use a strategy card at the table.

4. Insurance

When the dealer shows an ace, you can “insure” for half your bet; it pays 2 to 1 if the dealer has blackjack. In a 6-deck shoe the dealer has a ten under the ace only about 31% of the time, and you’d need 33.3% to break even. Across 15 million insurance bets in the simulation, insurance lost 7.5% — and taking it every time adds about 0.29% to the house edge of the whole game. “Even money” on your own blackjack is the same bet under another name.

What it adds up to

For a typical session of 200 hands at $25 ($5,000 wagered):

How you playAverage cost
Basic strategy, 3:2, dealer stands on soft 17≈ $21
Basic strategy, 6:5, dealer hits soft 17≈ $101
Mimic the dealer, 3:2, stands on soft 17≈ $283

Results swing widely in any one session — a range of roughly ±$800 either way for 200 hands — but over time the average wins out. Try your own table and style in the blackjack house edge calculator.

This is math education, not encouragement to gamble. Basic strategy lowers the house edge but doesn’t remove it. If gambling stops being fun, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER (U.S.).

Frequently asked questions

What is the house edge in blackjack with basic strategy?

About 0.42% in a common 6-deck game where blackjack pays 3:2 and the dealer stands on soft 17, based on 40 million simulated hands. If the dealer hits soft 17 it rises to about 0.66%.

How much worse is 6:5 blackjack?

It adds about 1.4 percentage points to the house edge. In simulation a 6-deck game went from 0.42% at 3:2 to 1.80% at 6:5 — more than four times as costly.

Should you ever take insurance in blackjack?

Not as a basic-strategy player. In a 6-deck shoe the dealer has a ten under an ace only about 31% of the time, but you need 33.3% to break even. In 15 million simulated insurance bets it lost 7.5%.

Is it a good strategy to play like the dealer?

No. Because you act first, you lose when you bust even if the dealer busts later. Mimicking the dealer had a house edge of about 5.7% in simulation — around 13 times worse than basic strategy.

Does never busting work in blackjack?

No. Standing on every hard 12 or more cost about 6% in simulation, because against a dealer 7 or higher your stiff hands usually lose anyway.

Sources

Written by Pramod Parnati, Founder, Calculator Suite. Published November 19, 2026. Found a mistake? Every number in this guide can be checked with the linked calculators — and we’ll fix anything that’s wrong.

More guides